[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [New Search]

Re: [T3] Bagging on technicians

Technicians are not paid on commission; they are paid based on the guidelines for a particular job out of a flat rate manual. While its true that if the job pays 1 hour and it takes you 2 you "eat your lunch", its just as true that if the job pays 3 hours and it takes you 2 hours to do it, you get paid for 3. The flat rate manual encourages technicians to work quickly and take shortcuts, and a good technician can make a good living by fitting 70-90 hours (or more) of flat rate time into their 40 hour work week. The problem becomes a less experienced technician will try to do the same thing to keep up, and take short cuts and do hack work in an attempt to the flat rate manual. My experience as a mechanic was also that the senior, more experienced technicians were given the "gravy" jobs; the high flat rate jobs that they could do quickly, while the newer guys like me were doing a lot of the grunt work that you couldn't hit the flat rate time, no matter what you did (like changing a motor in a cube van).

I'm very lucky that I have a local repair shop that I trust that I can bring any of my cars to (including my Fastback to get the carbs synced when I didn't have the tools to do it) because ALL of my recent dealer repair experiences have gone poorly.

The crack about "drugged up shade tree techs"  speaks volumes.

'68 Fastback

Jim McGarvey wrote:

To The people that don't believe in Mechanics.

I am a Dealer Technician, I started on VW's moved to Subaru's Became a SR Master Subaru Technican 10 years of hard work and studying. (one of only 50 in the US) left to do techline for KIA. Techline means when the dealer was unable to fix the vehicle I walked them through it. Now I fix Suzuki's and train technicians. It's not that only dropouts become Technicians. You have to think 60 or men design a vehicle with no thought being put in to the fact that some one has to fix it. Factory Scan tools cant keep up with technology. A tech is paid on comission. Which means if the job pays one hour and takes two. You just had a pay cut. I had a vehicle that the MAF sensor read 1 gram of and the vehicle ran fine bud would set the check engine lamp. I spent two weeks trying to figure this out. One gram diff. could becaused By the IAC motor, Throttle plate opening angle, engine RPM differance or just plain engine wear. Working on cars has gotten a lot harder and more technical over the last 23 years i've workid on them.
All the Doctors, teachers, enginers I've met could not make a living working on cars. I still do my own head work, rebuild auto and man. transmissions. Just under stand you get what you pay for!!! I am the best and you will pay for it. While I was at VW is still worked on Split windows. Because they wanted it done right and not hacked by some druged up shade tree tech. I make less pe hour but make more per year then most collage grads.

----- Original Message ----- From: "Constantino Tobio" <ctobio@gmail.com>
To: <type3@vwtype3.org>
Sent: Monday, January 31, 2005 6:24 PM
Subject: Re: [T3] New Fastback photos

That does worry me. Particularly in America, someone who is
intelligent who becomes a plumber or a mechanic is somehow not living
up to society's expectations, while vocational programs are aimed at
teenage malcontents or the intellectually challenged. The service
industry is careening towards being entirely populated by the
intellectual have-nots, while management and engineering is for the
intellectual haves. Oh, and I'm not just talking about inborn
abilities, but learning opportunity as well here.

No one seems to do their own work anymore. When I was a kid (and it
wasn't all that long ago) people still did their own oil changes. Now,
people look at ME funny when I tell them that NO ONE DOES MY OIL
CHANGES BUT ME. Not sure what that says about us as a society. The
auto industry and the auto repair industry has rather successfully
cowed people into believing that "cars are too hard to work on anymore
what with all the computers they have onboard." Meanwhile, your
average mechanic is little more than a parts-swapping grease monkey,
and I just don't have the confidence that their skills have evolved
commensurate with the evolution of technology.

Anyway, that's my rant for today. That's why I love forums like these-
lots of like-minded individuals who know their stuff and love getting
their elbows dirty.

On Mon, 31 Jan 2005 21:36:31 -0000, Dave Hall <dave@hallvw.clara.co.uk> wrote:

> Back when I was in high school, I worked
> at an auto parts store that largely sold to mechanics, professional
> and shade-tree. I could count on one hand the number of mechanics that
> could be trusted with working on a car..

That was something I noticed in years of teaching - virtually none of the
brighter kids wanted to be mechanics. There was an occasional one who was
particularly gifted at practical skills, at the expense of his other subjects.
Seems all the parents want their kids to become managers, academics or media
moguls. While we need some of them (I suppose), we need skilled mechanics,
plumbers, electricians etc too. Why do we not celebrate manual skills any more,
no matter what area it is shown in? I guess that's why we are happy with
slab-sided monstrosities rather than craft-rich buildings like the ones we saw
in Albany, NY. Bring back the craftsman (and woman - mmm all that

UK VW Type 3 & 4 Club

List info at http://www.vwtype3.org/list | mailto:gregm@vwtype3.org


[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [New Search]